Part brownie, part cookie, and 100% legendary. This Dave’s Pizza Garage original is fudgy, chewy, and addictive—our most famous dessert. Guests say it’s one of the most talked about desserts in Tallahassee. If you know, you know.
Start with something sweet—we won’t tell anyone. At Dave’s Pizza Garage, our desserts are made to finish strong, whether you’re treating yourself after pizza and wings or grabbing a sweet snack to go. From our famous brookies to hand-dipped milkshakes, these are the desserts Tallahassee craves most. Don’t sleep on Dave’s chewy chocolate chip cookies. It’s a recipe that he has been using since baking and selling cookies to pay for prom in high school!
Part brownie, part cookie, and 100% legendary. This Dave’s Pizza Garage original is fudgy, chewy, and addictive—our most famous dessert. Guests say it’s one of the most talked about desserts in Tallahassee. If you know, you know.
Soft, chewy, and baked fresh from Dave’s secret recipe. Packed with melty chocolate chips, these cookies are the perfect add-on for any order.
Your choice of Dave’s fresh-baked cookie or Brookie stuffed with your favorite ice cream and sprinkles. Sweet, chewy, and creamy in every bite. Created by Dave’s oldest son Tucker, this dessert sandwich is an original you won’t find anywhere else in Tallahassee.
Thick, creamy, and blended to order with your favorite flavor of ice cream. A Garage classic that proves why we’re more than just pizza—our shakes have fans all over Tallahassee.
Choose your favorite flavor and dig in. Whether you go Kid-size, Big Kid-size, or Pint To-Go, this classic treat hits the spot every time. Perfect for cooling off after hot Buffalo wings. 8 rotating flavors! Come find your favorite.