Big flavor, packed tight, and baked fresh in the Garage. Our calzones take all the bold taste of Dave’s Pizza Garage and fold it into a golden crust you can hold in your hands. Perfect for lunch, late-night cravings, or when you want all the cheesy, meaty goodness without the slice. A true Tallahassee favorite with Buffalo-style attitude.
Start with creamy ricotta cheese, then build your dream calzone from the bottom, up. Add your favorite meats, veggies, and extra cheese from our toppings list to make it exactly how you want. A customizable Garage classic perfect for picky eaters or adventurous foodies alike.
When one meat just isn’t enough. We load this calzone with bacon, beef, pepperoni, and sausage for a flavor-packed handheld feast. Built for serious appetites, this one might make you say “Uncle”!
Everything you love about a pepperoni pizza, folded up inside. Stuffed with mozzarella, pepperoni, oregano, and our signature sauce, then baked golden brown. Easy to eat, hard to share, and always a favorite in Tallahassee.
The ultimate ride for cheese lovers. We pack in mozzarella, feta, colby, and cheddar until every bite is oozing with melted goodness. Simple, rich, and always satisfying with a golden crust—it’s the classic calzone done the Dave’s Pizza Garage way.
Start with something sweet—we won’t tell anyone. At Dave’s Pizza Garage, our desserts are made to finish strong, whether you’re treating yourself after pizza and wings or grabbing a sweet snack to go. From our famous brookies to hand-dipped milkshakes, these are the desserts Tallahassee craves most. Don’t sleep on Dave’s chewy chocolate chip cookies. It’s a recipe that he has been using since baking and selling cookies to pay for prom in high school!
Part brownie, part cookie, and 100% legendary. This Dave’s Pizza Garage original is fudgy, chewy, and addictive—our most famous dessert. Guests say it’s one of the most talked about desserts in Tallahassee. If you know, you know.
Soft, chewy, and baked fresh from Dave’s secret recipe. Packed with melty chocolate chips, these cookies are the perfect add-on for any order.
Your choice of Dave’s fresh-baked cookie or Brookie stuffed with your favorite ice cream and sprinkles. Sweet, chewy, and creamy in every bite. Created by Dave’s oldest son Tucker, this dessert sandwich is an original you won’t find anywhere else in Tallahassee.
Thick, creamy, and blended to order with your favorite flavor of ice cream. A Garage classic that proves why we’re more than just pizza—our shakes have fans all over Tallahassee.
Choose your favorite flavor and dig in. Whether you go Kid-size, Big Kid-size, or Pint To-Go, this classic treat hits the spot every time. Perfect for cooling off after hot Buffalo wings. 8 rotating flavors! Come find your favorite.
Built for little hands to make BIG smiles! Every kids meal at Dave’s Pizza Garage comes with a cookie or applesauce and a drink, making us a family favorite in Tallahassee. Simple, tasty, and made to please even the pickiest eaters.
Buttery penne noodles topped with Parmesan ‘sprinkle cheese’, served with a warm breadstick. A simple and comforting option perfect for young diners.
Hand-breaded chicken nuggets, golden and crispy, served with fries, ketchup, and ranch. A fan-favorite kids meal that always disappears fast.
A classic combo kids love. One juicy meatball in red sauce served with spaghetti noodles and a warm breadstick. Easy, tasty, and just the right size.
A kid-sized pizza topped with a pepperoni smiley face—fun, delicious, and guaranteed to brighten your little one’s day.
Our pastas are comfort food classics, baked and sauced to perfection, proving that Dave’s Pizza Garage is more than just pizza in Tallahassee. Always served with fresh salad and breadsticks to soak up every last drop—that’s the Garage way.
Oven-baked perfection. Penne pasta layered with seasoned beef, creamy ricotta, and homemade red sauce, then smothered in melted mozzarella until golden and bubbling. Cheesy goodness, its ultimate dish for catering or dinner date meal in Tallahassee.
Your special occasion Garage indulgence. Crispy, hand-breaded chicken breast, topped with bubbling mozzarella and our house red sauce, all served over a bed of spaghetti. A signature dish that’s as filling as it is flavorful.
A timeless classic, done right. Juicy, seasoned meatballs served over perfectly cooked spaghetti and smothered in our rich, homemade red sauce. Comforting, filling, and a true fan-favorite pasta dinner in Tallahassee.
At Dave’s Pizza Garage, our pizzas are handcrafted with fresh dough, bold flavors, and a touch of Buffalo, NY pride. Perfect for families, game days, or a quick bite. Our pizzas bring Tallahassee the best mix of classic comfort and local flair. Available in Personal 10”, Small 12”, Large 16”, and Gluten-Free 10”.
Sweet with a kick in the mouth—this Dave’s Pizza Garage original starts with a golden honey base, layered with creamy ricotta, candied jalapeño relish, baked chicken, and crispy bacon, then topped with a rich colby-cheddar blend. The ultimate balance of sweet and spicy, and one of the most popular specialty pizzas at the Garage.
Simple, fresh, and straight to the point. Saucy and topped with ripe tomato, creamy fresh mozzarella, Parmesan and fragrant basil, this classic delivers Buffalo-style craftsmanship with a light, authentic Italian touch. A go-to for anyone looking for a fresh take on pizza night in Tallahassee.
Fresh, balanced, and built with horsepower. This specialty pie layers minced garlic, sun-dried tomatoes, onions, grilled chicken, spinach, and mozzarella, finished with a sprinkle of fresh basil. A light & hearty, flavor-packed option that proves why Dave’s Pizza Garage is known for the best specialty pizzas in Tallahassee.
A Dave’s Pizza Garage crowd favorite. From the man that set Dave on a path towards pizza. This special pie is built on an oil and spice base, then topped with Parmesan, onions, tomatoes, garlic, breadcrumbs, and mozzarella. Light, garlicky, and packed with flavor—this Buffalo-style specialty has earned its spot as one of the best alternative pizzas in Tallahassee.
Smoky, spicy, and straight from Tallahassee’s backyard. Topped with Bradley Country Store’s mild smoked sausage, onions, green peppers, and a sweet-heat kick of candied jalapeño relish, all covered in a gooey colby-cheddar blend. A true Dave’s Pizza Garage favorite that brings Buffalo-style attitude to Tallahassee pizza night.
Named after a bedtime story Dave read to his kids, it’s our unique take on the Hawaiian pizza. Sweet pineapple and savory ham mix with sautéed onions and peppers glazed in a teriyaki-brown sugar sauce. A tropical twist that brings bold, sweet-and-savory flavor to Tallahassee pizza lovers.
This pizza is the king of combination. Our Supremo features pepperoni, sausage, onion, green peppers, mushrooms, and black olives. A balanced, flavor-packed pie that brings together everything people love about classic pizza night with all the fixings.
Calling all meat lovers in Tallahassee. Your dream pizza is loaded with pepperoni, sausage, ham, bacon, and beef! The ultimate choice when you want all the meat. Perfect for sharing—or not sharing at all.
Crisp onions, green peppers, mushrooms, black olives, and fresh tomato come together on our signature crust. A fresh, flavorful option that makes vegetables the star of the show—perfect for vegetarians or anyone who wants a lighter pizza night.
Calling all pepperoni lovers in Tallahassee, this one’s for you! Loaded with layers of cup-and-char pepperoni baked to crispy perfection, this pizza packs big flavor into every slice. A fan favorite that is always a crowd-pleaser.
Keep it simple and delicious with our hand-tossed cheese pizza. Crafted with a whole milk mozzarella that stretches for days right out of the oven. Topped with our homemade sauce, this classic option is perfect for kids, families, or anyone who loves pizza in its purest form. Add your favorite toppings to make it your own.
Crisp veggies, bold toppings, and dressings worth the dip. At Dave’s Pizza Garage, our salads are fresh, healthy, and full of flavor—never an afterthought. Each one is big enough to stand on its own but pairs perfectly with pizza and wings. If you’re looking for an elevated lighter option in Tallahassee that still tastes amazing, our salads deliver.
Fall flavors done Garage-style. Crisp apples, red onions, dried cranberries, Bavarian nuts, feta, and baked chicken, tossed with a sweet-tangy honey lemon ginger dressing. A seasonal favorite in Tallahassee that’s healthy, tasty, and unique to Dave’s Pizza Garage.
Sweet, juicy, and full of summer flavor. Fresh blueberries, onions, Bavarian nuts, feta, and baked chicken, finished with a rich balsamic reduction. A Garage original that’s as refreshing as it is delicious—only available in the summer months.
Bright, refreshing, and built to chase away winter blues. Strawberries, mandarin oranges, onions, nuts, bleu cheese crumbles, and baked chicken, drizzled with honey lemon ginger dressing. A fan-favorite seasonal salad that’s light, tasty, and keeps things fresh all year long.
JoJo approved. From the garden to your plate. Fresh tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, shaved carrots, and green peppers, served with our house-made ranch. A fresh and tasty Tallahassee favorite that’s perfect for anyone wanting something light and flavorful.
Crisp green leaf lettuce, Parmesan, and crunchy croutons with creamy Caesar dressing. Add grilled chicken at no extra cost to make it a meal. A timeless favorite that’s as satisfying as it is healthy.
A Mediterranean classic with Tallahassee flair. Fresh tomatoes, onions, black olives, banana peppers, ham, and feta cheese, with a side of Greek dressing or upgraded with balsamic reduction. A healthy, flavorful option that proves salad can be just as crave-worthy as pizza.
Big flavor, stacked high, and always served with fries or chips plus a cookie treat. At Dave’s Pizza Garage, our sandwiches deliver the same bold taste as our pizzas and wings—sometimes messy, always filling and unforgettable. Whether you’re craving Buffalo-style tradition or a Tallahassee favorite, these handhelds pack serious flavor.
A Tallahassee original you won’t find anywhere else. Loaded with Bradley’s famous smoked sausage, sweet-heat candied jalapeños, and sautéed peppers and onions. Finished off with Boar’s Head honey mustard and creamy mayo on a toasted roll—Make this sandwich a weekly win just like the Florida State Seminoles.
Crispy, golden-breaded chicken topped with our house red sauce and layered with bubbling melted mozzarella, all baked to perfection on a toasted garlic bread roll. Hearty, cheesy, and a true fan-favorite comfort food in Tallahassee.
Big classic taste! Load up with juicy, seasoned meatballs smothered in our signature red sauce, top it with bubbling melted mozzarella, and serve it on a toasted crusty garlic bread roll. Hearty, cheesy, and downright delicious. The meatball sub you didn’t know you needed.
East Coast flavor done Garage-style. Thin-sliced roast beef, sautéed green peppers, onions, and mushrooms, layered with melty provolone, and finished with just the right size swipe of mayo. A fan-favorite Tallahassee cheesesteak that rivals Philly’s best.
A Buffalo, NY classic you won’t find anywhere else in Tallahassee. Tender roast beef dipped in au jus, piled high on a salty Kimmelweck roll. Finished with an optional a punch of horseradish. Straight out of Buffalo, served hot and juicy to your table.
Big flavor. Small bites. Perfect for sharing—or keeping all to yourself. At Dave’s Pizza Garage, our shareables bring together Buffalo-style comfort food and Tallahassee flavor. From crispy, cheesy breadsticks and golden-fried cauliflower bites to our legendary Pizza Logs, these appetizers are made for game nights, parties, and family dinners. Whether you’re craving cheesy, fried, savory, or even a little healthy, our shareables prove why everyone adds an appetizer when they order.
A true Buffalo staple and one of Dave’s signature menu items. Hand-rolled pepperoni pizza wrapped in a crispy fried egg roll, served with ranch and red sauce for dipping. Crispy, gooey, and unforgettable—these are the most talked-about shareable in Tallahassee.
Our nod to a Canadian classic. Golden fries topped with fresh mozzarella chunks and rich brown gravy. Comfort food doesn’t get more satisfying than this.
We take our thick golden fries and top them with crispy bacon, melted cheese, ketchup, and homemade ranch. Gooey, savory, and loaded with flavor—this shareable was built for hungry crowds.
Thick-cut, golden, and crispy. The perfect sidekick for any meal or a snack all by themselves. Sometimes fries don’t need anything fancy.
Fresh mozzarella and chopped tomato tossed with basil. Finished with a drizzle of balsamic reduction and olive oil. A perfectly balanced light, refreshing starter or shareable— a twist on a classic caprese salad.
Straight from the fryer and impossible to resist. Hand-breaded Wisconsin cheese curds, fried until golden, and paired with ranch and red sauce. Proof that fried cheese really does make everything better.
Crispy, golden-fried cauliflower bites with Dave’s signature wing sauce and ranch. A lighter way to bring the flavor of Buffalo wings to the table without the chicken.
Bite-sized, buttery-garlic Parmesan bread bites topped with mozzarella cheese, served with red sauce and Dave’s homemade ranch for dipping. Soft, chewy, and downright addictive—this one’s a Garage classic that Tallahassee can’t get enough of.
Brought down from Buffalo, NY by Dave himself. Our wings are fried crispy, tossed in bold sauces, and served with celery, carrots, and bleu cheese (ranch on request). Whether you go traditional or boneless, these are the wings Tallahassee can’t stop talking about. Perfect for game day, late-night cravings, or sharing with friends—just grab a napkin (or three). These legendary wings will make you the hero of the tailgate!
Sweet with a garlic sting at the end—literally. These wings blend sticky-sweet honey with a punch of garlic and just enough heat to keep you hooked. A fan-favorite balance of sweet and spicy that keeps you licking your fingers and naming these honey garlic wings a favorite in Tallahassee.
Bright, zesty, and full of bold citrus flavor. Our Lemon Pepper wings start with golden-crisp chicken, coated in a buttery, lemon-pepper rub that makes every bite pop. A refreshing twist that keeps fans coming back, proving why Dave’s Pizza Garage is the go-to for lemon pepper wings in Tallahassee.
A thick and creamy buttery garlic sauce that is downright addictive. Tossed in rich garlic butter and a sprinkle of Parmesan, these wings bring an Italian-inspired twist to Buffalo tradition. Crispy, savory, and cheesy—exactly why foodies say Dave’s has the best garlic parmesan wings in Tallahassee.
One bite and you’ll know why these wings are a Garage original favorite. We slow cook our signature Blackberry BBQ on the stovetop to make a sweet, tangy, and fruity kick that clings to every crispy wing. Unique, bold, and unforgettable—no other wing joint in Tallahassee has this flavor.
Smoky, honey-sweet with a tangy kiss, and perfectly sticky. Our Classic BBQ wings hit that comfort food sweet spot every time. Whether you’re feeding the family or fueling up for game day, these BBQ wings are proof that Dave’s Pizza Garage serves the most flavorful wings near FSU and beyond.
The wings that put us on the map. Straight from Buffalo, NY to Tallahassee, Dave’s personal recipe for these signature sauces bring authentic Buffalo-style heat and flavor in three levels: mild, medium, and hot. Crispy on the outside, juicy inside, and dripping with the sauce that keeps locals calling these the best wings in Tallahassee.
